A forensic investigation is only as good as the evidence it is built on. Whether you are handling a subrogation claim involving a failed appliance, a product liability case involving industrial equipment, or a large fire loss, the actions taken in the first 24 to 72 hours after an incident can determine whether a definitive cause is ever established — or whether the case comes down to dueling speculation.
This guide is written for insurance adjusters and attorneys who want to understand what evidence preservation matters, why it degrades quickly, and how to ensure a forensic engineer has what they need to reach defensible conclusions.
Why Evidence Disappears So Quickly
Several forces work against evidence preservation after a fire or mechanical failure:
- ■
Restoration and repair work often begins before a cause is established. Contractors remove debris, replace damaged components, and restore utilities; destroying physical evidence in the process. - ■
Weather and environmental exposure degrades evidence. A burned appliance sitting in a roofless structure is not the same appliance the investigator would have examined on day one. - ■
Well-meaning property owners and their contractors clean up. Ash, debris, and failed components are bagged and hauled to the landfill. - ■
Electronic data is overwritten. Building automation system logs roll over. Security camera footage is recorded over.
Each of these is preventable, but only if the parties involved know what to look for and act quickly.

What to Preserve: The Physical Evidence
In Fire Investigations
The origin area, the location where the fire started, is the most critical evidence in any fire case. Physical preservation of the origin area includes:
- Maintaining the debris in its post-fire position. Excavation of burn debris is a systematic process in fire investigation. When debris is cleared before an investigator arrives, that process becomes impossible or unreliable.
- Preserving the suspected ignition source. If a failed appliance, electrical component, or mechanical system is believed to have started the fire, it should be treated as evidence; not removed, moved, or discarded.
- Documenting the fire pattern with photographs before anything is touched. Burn patterns, char depth, smoke staining, and heat indicators tell the story of how a fire developed and where it began.
- Securing the structure against unauthorized access. Contamination of a scene by unauthorized entry, or by an opposing party’s investigator before a joint examination, can compromise the integrity of the investigation.
In Mechanical Failure Investigations
When a mechanical component fails and causes property damage or injury, the failed component itself is usually the most important piece of evidence:
- Do not repair or replace the failed component until it has been examined by an engineer. This is the single most common mistake made in property damage claims involving appliance failures, plumbing leaks, and equipment failures.
- Preserve the packaging, installation instructions, and purchase records for the failed product if available. These documents establish the product’s history and whether it was installed per the manufacturer’s specifications.
- Photograph the failed component in place, before removal. Once a component is removed and placed in a bag, the context of its installation; how it was connected, what surrounded it, what else may have contributed to its failure is gone.
- Ask contractors to keep what they remove. Plumbers and sprinkler contractors routinely discard failed valves, fittings, and supply lines during repairs. In a recent sprinkler freeze case, the removed check valve and sprinkler head proved the pipe failed from freezing, not from a defective part.
The Joint Examination
In large loss cases involving multiple parties, it is common practice to conduct a joint examination, a scheduled site inspection where all parties’ engineers examine the evidence at the same time. Joint examinations:
- Prevent accusations that evidence was disturbed by one party’s examiner before others had a chance to inspect it.
- Create a shared record of what was found and the condition of the evidence.
- Allow for destructive examination (disassembly, sampling, sectioning) to be conducted with all parties present.
If you are on a claim where subrogation is likely, consider issuing a preservation demand and proposing a joint examination early in the process. This protects your client’s ability to recover and ensures the evidence is handled fairly.
How Quickly to Engage a Forensic Engineer
For fire investigations: immediately — within 24 hours if possible.
Fire scenes degrade rapidly, and in active insurance claims, restoration contractors are often pushing to begin work as soon as the structure is cleared.
For mechanical failure cases: before any repair work begins.
In many claims, the property has already been partially remediated by the time the carrier authorizes a forensic investigation. The investigator then faces a degraded scene, missing components, and photographs taken by a non-engineer as the only record of what was found.
Early engagement is not expensive relative to the cost of a case built on inadequate evidence. A brief phone consultation with a forensic engineer at the outset of a complex claim costs little and often prevents costly mistakes.
What to Tell Your Insured or Client
When advising a property owner or claimant about evidence preservation, keep the message simple:
- Do not clean up, repair, or allow contractors to work in the affected area until a forensic engineer has inspected it.
- Photograph everything before anything is moved or removed and continue photographing throughout the cleanup process.
- Save all failed components, even if they appear unremarkable. What looks like a melted piece of plastic may be the most important evidence in the case.
- Notify their insurance carrier and any other potentially responsible parties before repairs begin, so that a joint examination can be arranged if needed.
Working With a Forensic Engineer
A well-run forensic investigation begins with a clear scope and fast mobilization. When you contact a forensic engineer about a new assignment, provide:
- The date and location of the incident
- A brief description of what failed or what burned
- The current condition of the scene or property
- Whether the property is secured and who controls access
- Any deadlines for repair or cleanup that are already in place
This information allows the engineer to assess urgency, identify any preservation issues that need to be addressed immediately, and propose a scope of work. In many cases a site inspection can be scheduled within a few days of initial contact.
About the Author
James Laird, PE, IAAI-CFI, CFEI, CVFI is the founder of Clear Analysis Engineering, PLLC (CAE Forensic) in Bellingham, Washington. He provides forensic mechanical engineering and expert witness services for insurance carriers, subrogation professionals, and attorneys throughout the Pacific Northwest and nationally. He has conducted over 2,000 forensic investigations across residential, commercial, industrial, and vehicle cases.
☎ (360) 761-2602
✉ JLaird@caeforensic.com
🌐 caeforensic.com
